Improve your credit score FAST.
Get started for free
Personal Loans up to $35k made simple
Get started

Rent to own Homes in Shirley, IN

Shirley, IN is a great place for affordable rent-to-own homes! With a median household income of over $53,000 and a median rent of $733, the Shirley, IN rent-to-own market is more affordable than the traditional housing market which has shown tremendous growth across the U.S. and with it, aggressive competition for home purchases. With the current housing shortage trend it can make it harder to become a homeowner, including in Shirley, IN. This means higher than average down payments for homes and higher qualification standards for conventional home loans. With a rent-to-own property, tenants are also buyers. You can live in the house for a set amount of time before you purchase it, meaning that you get to know the house, your neighbors, and your community before making the final purchase. This enables you and your family to make the right choice based on both information and experience. Rent-to-own is also a great alternative way to get into a home if you have bad credit or don't have enough saved for a down payment.

Check out Shirley, IN rent to own homes for sale, which may include auction properties, for sale by owner, and more.
Showing 1 - 44 of 440
512 CENTRAL AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Single Family Home
Anderson, IN 46012
3
2
1202 ft2
1915
1 of 21 3668 TUDOR PARK DR
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Townhouse/Condo
Indianapolis, IN 46235
2
2
1048 ft2
1973
1 of 24 9442 ORCHARD COVE DR
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
Wanamaker
Single Family Home
Indianapolis, IN 46239
2
2
1495 ft2
2021
4456 N KENYON AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
Devington
Single Family Home
Indianapolis, IN 46226
3
1
1598 ft2
1959
3545 S SADLIER DR
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
Five Points
Single Family Home
Indianapolis, IN 46239
3
2
1606 ft2
1957
5697 E 300 N
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Single Family Home
Greenfield, IN 46140
3
3
2086 ft2
1975
2025 PEARL ST
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Townhouse/Condo
Anderson, IN 46016
5
2
2144 ft2
1899
Hot
1108 NICHOL AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Townhouse/Condo
Anderson, IN 46016
5
3
1869 ft2
1898
8716 E Otter Dr
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Single Family Home
Selma, IN 47383
3
2
1300 ft2
1982
Hot
1 of 8 410 S 11TH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Townhouse/Condo
Noblesville, IN 46060
4
2
1450 ft2
1985
1 of 10 321 BEECHWOOD DR
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Townhouse/Condo
Noblesville, IN 46060
8
4
3600 ft2
1980
501 BEECH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Single Family Home
Connersville, IN 47331
2
1
576 ft2
1940
Hot
405 E BROADWAY AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Single Family Home
Arcadia, IN 46030
4
2
1535 ft2
1910
201 W WALNUT ST
MORE DETAILS +
Rent To Own
 
Single Family Home
Farmland, IN 47340
3
1
1345 ft2
1953
1 of 6 121 MERIDIAN ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Shirley, IN 47384
3
1
1356 ft2
1920
205 PENNSYLVANIA ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Shirley, IN 47384
2
1
962 ft2
1980
404 1ST ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Shirley, IN 47384
3
1
1008 ft2
1900
300 S MAIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Kennard, IN 47351
3
1
2013 ft2
1900
301 N MAIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Kennard, IN 47351
3
2
1556 ft2
1974
Hot
210 N MAIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac
 
Single Family Home
Kennard, IN 47351
3
1
1433 ft2
1940
New
1 of 3 9300 W STATE ROAD 38
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Shirley, IN 47384
2
1
972 ft2
2020
1 of 10 9218 S TOMAHAWK TRL
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Markleville, IN 46056
2
2
1350 ft2
1994
214 S STATE ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Markleville, IN 46056
3
1
1814 ft2
1947
6384 W COUNTY ROAD 750 S
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
3
2
1560 ft2
1991
310 N FRANKLIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
3
1
2286 ft2
1900
1 of 33 32 N MCCULLUM ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
5
2
1992 ft2
1900
223 N ADAMS ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Townhouse/Condo
Knightstown, IN 46148
4
2
3168 ft2
1900
104 W JACKSON ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
3
2
2099 ft2
1955
318 E BROWN ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
3
1
1614 ft2
1900
9125 S MILL RD
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
2
1
1720 ft2
1950
1 of 9 37 S ADAMS ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Knightstown, IN 46148
4
2
2383 ft2
1901
New
2483 N 600 E
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Greenfield, IN 46140
3
1
1008 ft2
1900
5686 N RAIDER RD
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Middletown, IN 47356
4
1
1276 ft2
1930
1 of 12 424 W BROAD ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Spiceland, IN 47385
4
1
1458 ft2
1992
215 E MAPLE ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Spiceland, IN 47385
3
1
1168 ft2
1950
310 E 5TH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Carthage, IN 46115
3
1
1440 ft2
1956
203 E CENTRAL AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Spiceland, IN 47385
2
2
1080 ft2
1950
5591 ARROWHEAD DR
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Greenfield, IN 46140
3
2
1713 ft2
1976
14 S MAIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Carthage, IN 46115
3
2
2672 ft2
1975
6126 S COUNTY ROAD 225 W
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Spiceland, IN 47385
2
2
1413 ft2
1975
206 S MAIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Carthage, IN 46115
3
2
3024 ft2
1975
7975 N MECHANICSBURG RD
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Middletown, IN 47356
3
1
1080 ft2
1960
Hot
7422 W COUNTY ROAD 750 N
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Middletown, IN 47356
2
2
2500 ft2
1960
5467 S 50 W
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Anderson, IN 46013
2
2
864 ft2
1976
Map
Sponsored Link

More Shirley, IN Property Resources

Rent to own Homes in Cities Near Shirley, IN

Browse all Rent to own Homes in Indiana

Neighborhoods in Shirley, IN

No neighborhoods found

Popular Zip Codes in Shirley, IN

No zip codes found

Buying a Home in Shirley, IN

Shirley, IN is seeing rapid growth and Shirley, IN's' housing market remains optimal with an average home price that is -64% below the 2025 national average. Shirley, IN is part of Hancock county and taxes are an important factor to consider when purchasing a home whether through rent to own or a traditional purchase. The average tax rate as of 2025 for county Hancock is 0.92% which is below the national average, which is 0.99%.

Median Home Price in Shirley, IN

Median Rent in Shirley, IN

Rent to own homes offer low monthly payments and flexible terms.