Improve your credit score FAST.
Get started for free
Personal Loans up to $35k made simple
Get started

Rent to own Homes in Otterbein, IN

Otterbein, IN is a great place for affordable rent-to-own homes! With a median household income of over $51,250 and a median rent of $747, the Otterbein, IN rent-to-own market is more affordable than the traditional housing market which has shown tremendous growth across the U.S. and with it, aggressive competition for home purchases. With the current housing shortage trend it can make it harder to become a homeowner, including in Otterbein, IN. This means higher than average down payments for homes and higher qualification standards for conventional home loans. With a rent-to-own property, tenants are also buyers. You can live in the house for a set amount of time before you purchase it, meaning that you get to know the house, your neighbors, and your community before making the final purchase. This enables you and your family to make the right choice based on both information and experience. Rent-to-own is also a great alternative way to get into a home if you have bad credit or don't have enough saved for a down payment.

Check out Otterbein, IN rent to own homes for sale, which may include auction properties, for sale by owner, and more.
Showing 1 - 44 of 191
505 S MAIN ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Otterbein, IN 47970
4
1
1356 ft2
1945
1 of 6 509 E BENTON ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Oxford, IN 47971
3
2
1780 ft2
1900
1 of 67 5773 N 820 E
MORE DETAILS +
Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac
 
Single Family Home
Attica, IN 47918
4
4
3105 ft2
2000
307 S SHEETS ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Oxford, IN 47971
4
2
2143 ft2
1890
4336 HAYLOFT DR
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
West Lafayette, IN 47906
4
4
2433 ft2
2017
619 WILSHIRE AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac
Barbarry Heights
Single Family Home
West Lafayette, IN 47906
4
4
3012 ft2
1977
1301 WASHINGTON ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
Miller
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47905
3
2
1584 ft2
1920
New
4485 S 175 West Road
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
6
7
10626 ft2
1989
1000 HARTFORD ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
Lincoln
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47904
3
1
1938 ft2
1901
3445 OLD ROMNEY RD
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
Triple Jay
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
1
1120 ft2
1945
359 LIMESTONE CT W
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
4
2
1903 ft2
2019
1 of 9 806 E RIVER RD
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Attica, IN 47918
3
1
1360 ft2
1958
1 of 10 1817 JACKSON ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
Columbian Park
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47904
3
1
1686 ft2
1901
2625 MIDLEX CT
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
St. Lawrence McAllister
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47904
3
1
864 ft2
1949
3608 GOLDEN LN
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
Old Farm
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
4
2
2083 ft2
1964
3212 WALTON ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
Sherwood
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
1
1456 ft2
1969
1 of 9 5838 PROPHETS ROCK RD
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
West Lafayette, IN 47906
3
3
2784 ft2
1973
1921 SHASTA DR
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
Commanche
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
1
975 ft2
1965
812 S WAGON WHEEL TRL
MORE DETAILS +
Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
2
1452 ft2
1978
New
1 of 20 402 BAXTER ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Attica, IN 47918
2
1
1663 ft2
1940
1 of 10 3058 PORTSMOUTH DR E
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
2
1028 ft2
1978
Hot
815 SOMERSET DR
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
Glen Acres
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47905
3
1
1344 ft2
1954
1 of 5 3236 RUNYON DR
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
1
2377 ft2
2006
1 of 9 401 S PARK AVE
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Fowler, IN 47944
4
3
2148 ft2
1985
1 of 44 125 TOMAHAWK LN
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Battle Ground, IN 47920
3
2
864 ft2
1977
708 E 6TH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Fowler, IN 47944
3
2
3078 ft2
1905
110 W LITHIA ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Attica, IN 47918
4
1
2093 ft2
1940
1 of 9 3922 PENBROOK LN
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
Potter Hollow
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47905
4
2
2581 ft2
1969
1217 S PERRY ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Attica, IN 47918
3
2
2328 ft2
1980
Hot
2617 MARGESSON XING
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47909
3
3
2440 ft2
2004
Hot
6211 HUSTON RD
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
West Lafayette, IN 47906
2
1
1344 ft2
1958
Hot
129 E 4TH ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Williamsport, IN 47993
1
1
1036 ft2
1900
Hot
208 N BURKE ST
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Wolcott, IN 47995
1
1
1698 ft2
1900
New
404 W NORTH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Wolcott, IN 47995
3
1
1589 ft2
1900
1 of 13 1406 MEADOWBROOK CT
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Lafayette, IN 47905
4
2
1920 ft2
1965
114 S MAINE ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Remington, IN 47977
4
1
1560 ft2
1907
11703 W US HIGHWAY 24
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Wolcott, IN 47995
3
2
1902 ft2
1910
New
111 E SOUTH RAILROAD ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Remington, IN 47977
3
2
1350 ft2
1995
Hot
11926 N 400 W
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Romney, IN 47981
3
2
1512 ft2
1996
10926 N 350 W
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
New Richmond, IN 47967
3
2
1755 ft2
1996
513 S WABASH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
New Richmond, IN 47967
3
1
1275 ft2
1961
102 E WABASH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Auction
 
Single Family Home
Wingate, IN 47994
3
2
2048 ft2
1956
110 E NORTH ST
MORE DETAILS +
Pre-Foreclosure (Lis Pendens)
 
Single Family Home
Goodland, IN 47948
2
1
940 ft2
1947
306 W Washington Street
MORE DETAILS +
REO Foreclosure
 
Single Family Home
Reynolds, IN 47980
3
2
2672 ft2
1900
Map
Sponsored Link

More Otterbein, IN Property Resources

Rent to own Homes in Cities Near Otterbein, IN

Browse all Rent to own Homes in Indiana

Neighborhoods in Otterbein, IN

No neighborhoods found

Popular Zip Codes in Otterbein, IN

No zip codes found

Buying a Home in Otterbein, IN

Otterbein, IN is seeing rapid growth and Otterbein, IN's' housing market remains optimal with an average home price that is -58% below the 2025 national average. Otterbein, IN is part of Benton county and taxes are an important factor to consider when purchasing a home whether through rent to own or a traditional purchase. The average tax rate as of 2025 for county Benton is 0.82% which is below the national average, which is 0.99%.

Median Home Price in Otterbein, IN

Median Rent in Otterbein, IN

Rent to own homes offer low monthly payments and flexible terms.